How Halo: The Master Chief Collection Rebounded To Become A Fan-Favorite Compilation

Fans were thrilled when Halo: The Master Chief Collection, a compilation of mainline Halo games was revealed in 2014. It featured countless enhancements to multiplayer and ways for fans to interact with it. The compilation launched with Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary (originally Halo 2 Anniversary), Halo 3 Anniversary, and Halo 4 but there were many problems. The Master Chief Collection looked like it would soon be one of the warning signs of unfulfilled potential for the game industry.

The poor launch, lackluster feature set and broken matchmaking might have been how we looked back at Halo: The Master Chief Collection 2021. But developer 343 Industries was not satisfied with the release of an insatiable product to commemorate Xbox’s most popular franchise. Three43 Industries was able to correct the situation and elevate the Master Chief Collection to a leading industry model for listening to and acting on players’ feedback. We talked to key representatives of the Master Chief Collection group.


Before Launch 

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

Wake me when You Have Need

The Master Chief Collection (Halo: The Master Chief Collection) was created in 2014. It is a celebration of the 10th anniversary of Halo 2 and the entire Master Chief’s story. 343 Industries, which was founded to take over the Halo franchise from Bungie following Bungie’s split from Microsoft in 2007, was currently working on Halo 5: Guardians, but a separate team within the studio began exploring ways to celebrate Halo 2’s anniversary similar to how it did in 2011 with Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary.

The basic idea of Halo 2 Anniversary, which includes revamped visuals and audio, all-new cutscenes from renowned visual effects company Blur Studios, and terminals that connect the story to that of future games, expanded on what the team did with its inaugural project with Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary. 343 even remade some fan-favorite maps from Halo 2’s multiplayer from the ground up, giving players modern, high-fidelity versions. 343 Industries also wanted to decrease friction between Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary’s classic campaign and multiplayer. 

The team started to think about what they could do to celebrate both the Xbox One’s launch and Master Chief’s history to this point. Max Szlagor, design director of the Xbox One project said that Max was excited to think about a larger project which could encompass all of these titles. The design challenge was to look at how we could bring together the Halo titles in such a seamless way, that it is easy for users to navigate between them.

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

Halo: The Master Chief Collection’s emphasis was not to deliver a completely faithful experience of how Halo: Combat Evolved through Halo 4 played at the time of their respective releases. 343 Industries aimed to make these games more accessible today. Szlagor states that “We wanted to recreate the feeling of playing these games the way people remember it.” The evaluation was based on ‘How do you rebuild this mode?’ It was an evaluation of ‘How do we rebuild this mode or that map?’. The maps were modified: weaponry, game modes, and a wide range of things. These changes are meant to improve the quality of maps. You can engage in more of these activities, so fill up the sandbox and feel great.

MCC developers explored things such as user interface and matchmaking systems to find commonalities among the various games. All the games should be connected with matchmaking to enable players to jump between different titles within the collection. This was the consensus of the MCC team. Not only that, but Master Chief Collection unified control schemes, and added leaderboards to the campaign, as well as special features and achievements to give additional replay value to the campaigns many had already played through multiple times.

Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary and Halo 2 Anniversary were clearly the biggest leaps forward from the original versions, but Halo 3 and 4 also received boosts, with 60 frames-per-second performance and cleaned up user interfaces. Szlagor does not want to overlook the enormity of the Halo 3 & 4 improvements. It’s an important deal for these games, he said. These games are optimized for specific hardware.

343 Industries felt proud of the creations as it approached launch on 11/11/2014. It was a great opportunity for new and experienced Halo gamers to play the game, and to learn more about Master Chief before they release Halo 5 Guardians in 2015. The Master Chief Collection was not launched as planned and quickly became associated with disastrous launches.

Launch reception

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

Bring Back The Covenant Their Bomb

It received a strong critic’s praise when Halo: The Master Chief Collection was launched. Game Informer and high praise from most other outlets given access prior to launch. As the server opened and players attempted to get into the multiplayer game, it became obvious that the PVP section was not up to par.

Online game mode issues were the most common complaint from players. This included in-game statistics that were inaccurate and unbalanced team compositions as well as matchmaking problems. In-game chat was poor at best and players had to wait ridiculously long loads times. The campaigns proved to be solid but the popularity of Halo: The Master Chief Collection’s highly anticipated compilation meant that the game’s multiplayer was unable to function properly.

343 Industries was and Xbox were both hit hard by criticisms and fans due to the difficulties that followed the launch. Halo, The Master Chief Collection has been criticized for its disastrous launch. The collection’s poor performance shocked players, but 343 Industries was equally surprised. Szlagor said, “That was certainly not what we anticipated.” We learned a lot from this experience, especially in the context of such a huge project with no infrastructure for testing online services on the same scale as what’s required to do something so big.

Both the Xbox representative and the developer recommended that users exit and re-enter matchmaking immediately if the system doesn’t start working within a few minutes. However, despite Xbox’s claim to be “actively investigating the issue”, the vast majority of issues with the compilation would continue for months. The Master Chief Collection’s executive producer Dan Ayoub apologized for the “unjustified” complaints. Ayoub said to the community “You deserve better” and then laid out a set of server-side solutions that would improve the game’s current state. 

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

A game like Halo: Master Chief Collection is a large-scale title. We made every effort for a smooth launch, but there were issues. Ayoub stated that they are committed to fixing these problems as soon as possible to get everyone into matches. We are committed to making Halo the best experience possible.

The problems continued for nearly two weeks following launch. 343 Industries’ head Bonnie Ross offered another apology. This was largely in keeping with Ayoub’s feelings that the community deserved worse and that the team would make amends to the fans. On November 24, 2014, she said that “I personally regret this.” “Our team works around the clock to resolve these issues.”

The issues persisted after the launch window. 343 Industries, Microsoft and others called for Halo: Spartan Strike to be delayed in Windows. This allowed them to devote their efforts to fixing matchmaking. 343 Industries created a plan to get it to all players later in the month. Szlagor states, “This really was an important point for us. We looked at things such as building Halo Insider programs and pivoting to make our communication more transparent.” This will allow us to have a greater dialog with the community and be more honest.

With community faith at an all-time low, 343 Industries needed to regain player trust and work to make Halo: The Master Chief Collection not only the product the company originally envisioned, but improve upon every facet to create the compilation fans deserved.

MCC expansion

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

It’s a Good Idea, I Believe We Are Just Starting

Master Chief Collection included 2011’s Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary (Halo 2 Anniversary), Halo 3 Anniversary, Halo 3 Anniversary, Halo 3 Anniversary, Halo 3 Anniversary, Halo 3 Anniversary, Halo 3 Anniversary, Halo 3 Anniversary as well as all of the multiplayer maps, extra features, and Halo 4 at its launch. 343 Industries started looking at ways to improve the game for players after the obvious state was discovered. As 2014 winded down, 343 Industries released a blog post detailing the first steps of rectification. 343 Industries announced that every Master Chief Collection member would be eligible for a month of Xbox Live Gold free, as well as an exclusive avatar and in-game nameplate. Not only that, but 343 Industries added an extra remake of a Halo 2 map, plus the campaign of Halo 3: ODST to the Master Chief Collection at no additional cost. 

343 Industries published the March 2015 patch that was perhaps the biggest to Master Chief Collection’s party system and matchmaking systems. With the six-month anniversary of the launch of the collection fast approaching, critics and players began to question whether the project could be saved. However, the development team wasn’t giving up. Both 343 Industries as well as Xbox doubled down on their commitment to fixing this compilation.

Head of Xbox Phil Spencer stated that “Going into launch, our internal processes had indicated that we had a ready-to-launch game,” Game Informer at Game Developers Conference 2015. “Then, when it launched, we learned some things we didn’t know going into the launch – which is something we need to get better at; you can’t simulate the real-world environment inside of any sterile, fixed environment.”

To remedy this problem, the development team continued implementing deeper and more solid lines of communication with active and enthusiastic members of the community. “Reaching out to our communities is super important in engaging with them,” lead producer Michael Fahrny says. We would have one. secret sauce We call them Reclaimers because of their success with MCC in the past few years. These people are ambassadors for the community. We give them access to a lot of the ideas, builds, features, content – all that stuff that we’re doing for MCC – and we get raw feedback from them. These people help us to assess our readiness level and gauge how the community will react.

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

343 Industries has been more dependent on its gaming community in the years since Master Chief Collection was launched. Community managers, developers who are embedded in the various communities, are now essential members of most game studios. 343 established a flighting program where developers could communicate with Halo Insiders and help ensure that the game reaches certain goals to strengthen their relationship with the community.

The matchmaking process is one of the many checks the team has to go through in order to ensure that they are running on time. This takes between 30 and 40 seconds. Producer Sean Swidersky said that flying is like our backbone. We will do everything that we can to fly as many flights as possible, if there is time. This is an important part of the development process.

The team at The Master Chief Collection worked hard to make the game better and provide the products that fans desired. The performance of the game began to improve after many patches were released and servers received updates. The fixes to matchmaking and the overall multiplayer experience continued rolling out, and as the product stabilized in the year following launch, 343 Industries once again returned to focusing on content. In 2015, The Master Chief Collection released Halo 3: OdST. As a result fan feedback, Halo: Reach was added to the compilation in 2019. 

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

“We are constantly thinking about the contents of our collections and it’s always a question mark. How can we make them better?” Szlagor agrees. The Master Chief Collection has a compelling story. There was also the question, “Thematically, is it logical to include?” [ODST and Reach]? Fan perspective is that any Halos is better than all of them. There was definitely some discussion around that and it was just a matter of what could we do in what time frame and what makes sense for the theme.”

The reason that new content and updates continue to be added to The Master Chief Collection is because the entire team has a deep appreciation for the Halo franchise even before they started their jobs. 343 Industries is not only a group of long-term developers. It also includes those who have worked on Halo mods and were involved in the Halo Esports Scene. This results in a continuous stream of passion projects, many which eventually make it to the MCC.

Fahrny believes that we are constantly surprised by the new ideas we have. Then we discuss it with each other and determine if we can make it to MCC. We end up doing it more often than we should because we love Halo and it will be fun. Then we go through the flight and everyone really enjoys it. These are the things we end up doing. It was this way that the Firefight option options for Season 8 were born.

Halo 5 Guardians is not the primary Halo title. Infinite will launch in earnest December 8th. 343 has stated that they have no plans for it to be added into the Master Chief Collection. 343 Industries is proving that staying with a title, even if it launches in an awful state, pays off, despite the MCC and seasonal updates.

“The thing I’m proud of is how committed the team is to solving this problem – that commitment to delivering what our customers want is great,” Spencer told Game Informer In that interview from 2015. In that 2015 interview, she said, “Now, anyone can throw a stone at me and tell me, ‘Hey! We shouldn’t be in this position in the first place.’ That’s fine, however nobody has thrown their hands up in dismay. “The team doubled down.”

The End of the Road

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

Finalizing This Fight

343 Industries continues to support The Master Chief Collection, making it one of the most recognizable redemption stories in video games. 343 Industries jumped to PC after receiving improvements on Xbox Series X/S, which were launched with the new system in 2020.

For the Master Chief Collection team, bringing the product to PC was an important step in the project’s post-launch lifecycle, but before they committed to doing it, they wanted to make sure they could do it right. PC has never been a top priority for us, as studios. What does it actually mean to have a PC game that is modern? Can we even bring The Master Chief Collection – all the games in the collection – up to that standard?” Fahrny says. “We sat down and did a lot of evaluations of competitive products – good and bad things that competitors have done – and we built a plan around it, and then evaluated it. Then we said “We believe that we can accomplish this, and we feel we can do an excellent job.” We can also look back at our mistakes and learn from them.

This time, 343 Industries was much more methodical about how it approached bringing the collection to this new platform, rolling the games out one by one rather than all at once. Each of six Halo: The Master Chief Collection titles was made available to PC gamers over the course of one year. 343 Industries could learn from its mistakes one title at time with the rolled out approach. It was then easier to manage and could be applied at launch to solve any problems. Reach’s interpolation at high refresh rates was not meeting the expectations of the developer studio. Reach then improved the system within Reach and ensured that all five titles met their standards.

It was made possible by the honesty and communication that the team had gained during its early, rough days of launching the Xbox One edition. This was a great example of how the team has improved its process for ensuring that a game launches on time and listening to community feedback to make the game better over the years. The team even introduced cross-platform play in 2020 – a huge leap forward when you consider how many troubles the game initially had only executing single-platform multiplayer – and mod support to the PC version this past summer. Halo: The Master Chief Collection still receives updates on all platforms.

Halo: The Master Chief Collection

Although 343 has no plans to end support for Halo: The Master Chief Collection in the future, the eight season that began in October will be the final season for this long-running compilation. In order not to offer seasonal updates simultaneously for Master Chief Collection or Infinite, 343 plans to continue to update MCC with new features and fix. However, it will deliver smaller updates than large-scale, regular updates.

Matt Hohl, senior producer says that MCC support is evolving at high levels. We still have mod tools that can deliver. “We still have more games. [Custom Game Browser] to deliver. As stewards for these old games, we still view ourselves. […]We look forward to next year’s complimentary relationship between MCC and Infinite.

As 343 Industries turns its focus towards Halo Infinite, you can see that the lessons the studio learned from the early stumbles and later success of Halo: The Master Chief Collection paid dividends. In addition to listening to community feedback and delaying Infinite a full year (even if it meant missing the opportunity of being an Xbox Series X/S launch title), the studio held multiple technical tests during summer 2021. These tests gave the opportunity for players to give input on the future direction of Infinite’s multiplayer, which is free-to-play.

Halo Infinite

Fahrny states that the community and the flighting program were a huge help to us. “We have been the ones leading the charge. We feed all this back to other studio teams, so we can keep the great work that helped us succeed.” It’s really been great to see.

Xbox and 343 industries announced an unexpected soft-launch for the Halo Infinite multiplayer during the Xbox 20th Anniversary livestream. All players were given immediate access to a beta which gives them full access to the suite. The launch will take place on December 8, 2021. The multiplayer’s Battle Pass has been slowing down and players gave feedback. 343 Industries staff have begun to implement changes. 

Now, as the team moves forward into what appears to be a very promising new chapter, it carries with it the valuable, often-harsh lessons it learned following the troubling launch of Halo: The Master Chief Collection. The team is hopeful that subsequent launches won’t have to be as painfully redesigned like the celebratory compilation. Now that developers are interacting on such an intimate level with their community, it is clear that The Master Chief Collection has made a significant impact on the direction of 343 Industries.


Click the banner to learn more about Halo Infinite.

#Halo #Master #Chief #Collection #Rebounded #FanFavorite #Compilation