The first Batman movie was pure World War 2 political propaganda

If you’ve been on social media or YouTube over the last decade, chances are that you’ve seen people complaining about the political plotlines and messages in modern superhero stories. “I just want to enjoy superhero stories without politics!” is a fairly common gripe — mostly from a subset of the audience that disagrees with whatever the perceived message might be.

Superhero stories were always politically charged from their inception. The American pride and power is represented by Homelander, Captain America’s punching Hitler in 1941. The Boys Robert Pattinson describes how he learned to become a progressive, responsible billionaire. BatmanIn the biggest political discussions of their times, super heroes have been ingrained. That goes all back to the horrible theatrical Batman version.

Batman and Robin: An Evening with Batman and Robin

Columbia Pictures

Columbia Pictures launched in 1943 BatmanThe serial was shown in theatres throughout the United States. This is the original live action portrayal of Boy Wonder and Caped Crusader, featuring Lewis Wilson and Douglas Croft. They are the youngest actors ever to play Bruce Wayne or Dick Grayson.

The 1943 was today’s date BatmanIt may look like a serial with a small budget, but Columbia Pictures invested a lot in marketing it back then, regularly releasing its sequel, 1949, and putting a lot more effort and attention into its advertising. Batman and Robin, as “An Evening With Batman and Robin.” These successful re-airings kept Batman in the public eye, right until Adam West took up the cowl in the 1960s.

The 1943 serial introduced some key elements of Batman lore to film audiences for the first time, including the Bat Cave (sometimes called the “Bat’s Cave”) and Alfred’s redesign. (Prior to the serial, Alfred was portly — a far cry from his elegant, thin iteration in modern comics.)

The serial was popular in its initial release but critics found it absurd. In his 1971 book, Raymond William Stedman, a critic of the serial, wrote: The Serials: Suspense, Drama and Drama by Installment, “This wartime serial garnered some good press notices, although, from the vantage point of the 1970s, it scarcely deserved them.”

The 1943 BatmanThe serial featured unconvincing performances from Wilson and Croft, as well as cheesy effects. The serial also lacks any appearances from Batman’s iconic rogues gallery. Joker, it seems, was cast at one point in the serial, judging by early promotional material, before Columbia opted to present an original villain, Doctor Daka, as Batman’s adversary.

However, the 1943 Batman was missing Catwoman, Penguin, and the like, it wasn’t missing out on a political angle. As with many wartime serials it was political propaganda that presented America as the only force fighting unrelenting Tyranny. It did this by using the vile Yellow Peril stereotypes to convey its message, making it one of America’s most grueling chapters.

Yellow Peril and Doctor Daka

Columbia Pictures

When people discuss 1943’s Batman In the current era they frequently point out the racism of the government, especially in Doctor Daka’s characterization. He’s a Japanese nationalist and loyal soldier under Emperor Hirohito. He forms an alliance with Gotham’s criminal underworld, using them to help develop an atom-smasher that can dismantle America’s infrastructure. In order to get people to help him, he transforms them into zombies. He’s a true threat, but the serial credits that not to the usual complicated Batman villain motivations, but due to his Japanese origins. He is often referred to by his henchmen using slurs. Batman, upon confronting Daka, immediately calls him “a Jap.”

Daka could have easily been called Fu Manchu because he is a representative of the Yellow Peril paranoia. It likely goes without saying that Daka isn’t played by a Japanese actor, but by decidedly white actor J. Carrol Naish. Naish was eventually nominated for multiple Oscars (including for playing an Italian man in 1943’s SaharaHowever, here he portrays Daka as an Orientalist Caricature. He speaks in a high-pitched voice with an exaggerated accent, and takes a passive role, hiding behind henchman — meant to contrast with Batman’s comparative masculinity as a fearless fighter.

Columbia created a symbol of defeat for Batman in order to represent America’s war against Japan. In this serial, Batman is treated as a stand-in for American virtue, while Daka is the evil foreign force — a proxy for the real-world target of the American war machine at that time. The 1943 was turned upside down by all of this. Batman into a feel-good story, designed to reinforce confidence in America’s war effort and help vilify America’s enemy. But it does so in ways that not only promote racial stereotypes, but also specifically justify some of America’s wartime atrocities during the war.

America is right, and it has never been wrong

Columbia Pictures

Batman1943 believes that America always wins, and everyone who is opposed to this view is an intruder who must be silenced. Daka is evil for standing with America against America. His henchmen are evil because they’re all criminal hirelings, as well as traitors to their country. One potential henchman however, whom Daka abducts straight from prison, is proud to be an American and refuses to give up to Daka. Daka then uses his technology on the man to get the data he needs, and turns him into an automated zombie.

Anti-Japanese imagery is baked into the serial’s setting and background. Daka’s lair is located in Little Tokyo, in the “Japanese House of Horrors,” a wax museum filled with depictions of Japanese soldiers capturing and killing Americans. Many of the wax statues are secretly Daka’s guards. The House of Horrors depicts is built around making Japanese people look frightening and monstrous — not just because they might murder American soldiers, but because they have a museum celebrating such killings.

Worst: Batman justifies America’s internment camps, which disrupted more than 120,000 lives during World War II, as peaceful American citizens were incarcerated due to their cultural background. As the narration over the introduction of Daka’s lair and Little Tokyo says:

“This was part of a foreign land, transplanted bodily to America and known as Little Tokyo. Since a wise government rounded up those shifty-eyed Japs, it has become virtually a ghost street, where only one business survives, eking out a precarious existence on the dimes of curiosity-seekers.”

Under internment, Japanese-Americans were forced to sell off their property — losing businesses, vehicles, and personal possessions — before being locked behind barbed wire for four years and given Loyalty Tests to determine their dedication to America. It was common to find that camp incarcerees were horrified that the government thought they weren’t loyal American citizens. Although the testing generally showed that there was no danger to the camp residents, internment continued until 1946.

Robin and Batman, on the other hand, view the Japanese to be enemies of the United States. Batman’s use of a racial slur in particular is a low point for the character, a siding with paranoid bigotry that was demonstrably unfounded even in its day.

It was fair for the time. Not quite.

Columbia Pictures

Many people justify the racist standards of older media by saying it’s just “standard for its time.” In this case, it isn’t true: Yellowface performances like Naish’s were controversial and criticized even back in the 1940s. The same can be said for other adaptations or superhero serials that exoticized and misunderstood foreign culture, but did not villainize them in such an extreme way.

1941’s Captain Marvel’s AdventuresOne of the most iconic superhero serials, “The First Superhero Serial” pits Billy Batson against The Scorpion. He is a scientist who was transformed using ancient Siamese magic after he wrongly entered an ancient tomb. He’s ultimately defeated when the people of Siam turn the magic against him yet again. While Siam — now modern-day Thailand — is treated as an exotic foreign culture, it isn’t subject to constant slurs and dehumanization.

And 1946’s famous Superman radio series Adventures of Superman, which pitted Superman against the Ku Klux Klan in the 16-part serial “Clan of the Fiery Cross,” took pains to portray Chinese-American characters in sympathetic roles, as one of the minorities threatened by the Klan. In this case, Superman came out against racism, exposing the Klan’s real-world codewords and hateful practices to an audience who otherwise might not have been aware of them. Stetson Kennedy was an activist who investigated the Klan. Unlike 1943’s Batman, which justifies bigotry, “Clan of the Fiery Cross” was aimed at fighting it. (Though it’s notable that the reasoning was still nationalist — China was America’s ally against Japan in the war, and pro-Chinese sentiment was as much a part of the war effort as anti-Japanese messaging.) Meanwhile, later serials, including 1948’s SupermanThe book, which was less focused on political and race moments and more on supervillains, had a similar effect.

The 1943 Batman stands as an anomaly — a point where Batman was used to promote xenophobic nationalism. The serial can be like experiencing a time travel in the most horrible ways. Audiences are left with very little to appreciate due to its slow pace and simple plot. This serial, aside from its shocking racism, is completely forgettable in an age where Batman stories are memorable.

But it’s important not to forget the history of our most iconic characters. It’s important to see how far we’ve come in terms of storytelling. The days of watching Batman fight gangsters with their hair glued down are gone. Cinema has raised our standards, and Batman’s cinematic debut just doesn’t meet them.

This 1943 serial has the Batman story that is unlike any other. Perhaps that is what makes this almost 80-year-old tale unique. It could be that it is a complete disaster. Frank Miller’s attempt to pitch his graphic novel was the closest Modern Batman has ever come to the overt racism that the original serial had. Holy TerrorAs a Batman story. DC was reluctant to publish the comic. They had every right to be cautious.

The 1943 BatmanSerial is Tubi allows streaming for free, with ads support.